The death of a dog can have just as much of an impact on you as when you lose a human family member or friend. If you’ve ever had a dog who died, you know the feeling firsthand.
While dogs can’t talk or laugh with you like another person can, they’re loyal beyond words and build memories in their own ways: that silly face they make mid-belly rub, their classic “give me attention” bark and the way they snuggle up under the covers when it’s cold. Those quirks and traits are what build an incredible bond between dogs and their people.
It’s no wonder the question of afterlife comes up constantly when a dog dies. People, both spiritual and not, wonder whether their dog is happy, comfortable and safe. Beyond simply hoping their dog has gone to a better place, though, some people even question whether their pet is still there, in the afterlife, watching over them.
When Spirits Remain
Whether you believe in a higher power or not, it’s hard to argue when countless people claim to have encounters with pets who have died.
Take the story of Hobbes, the dog of Robert, Kathy and their son. Hobbes died while the son was away at college, but they waited until he was home to share the sad news with him. When their son learned of his dog’s death, however, he was confused. He’d just seen and petted Hobbes in the hallway.
Or take Barbara, whose dog, Skila, used to go with her to her chiropractor appointments. When Barbara got a call from her chiropractor saying he’d seen Skila running through the hallway — after Skila had died — it was hard to deny the dog’s spiritual presence.
Beyond seeing pets after they’ve died, though, many people have other minor encounters. Some might feel their dog brush against their leg or hear the jingle of their collar coming down the stairs, for example.
Coping With Pets’ Deaths
People like Kim Sheridan completely understand and have even devoted their lives to helping others cope with the death of their pets. In fact, Kim’s book, Animals and the Afterlife, recounts dozens of other stories similar to the ones above.
And Kim isn’t the only one. Amanda Linette Meder, owner of a spiritual living blog, sticks to 10 foolproof signs your dog is trying to reach you from the afterlife.
Some of those signs include:
- Hearing your dog’s paws on the floor.
- Hearing panting or sighing, like your dog wants to come in from the backyard.
- Briefly seeing your dog from the corner of your eye.
Given the amount of people who experience these “signs,” could dog spirits really remain after they die?
The Scientific Explanation
Of course, for the firm non-believers, the science behind why these encounters happen also offers an interesting angle.
Psychologists John Bowlby and John Archer claim the “reunion theory” has something to do with why people see, hear and sense their dogs, even after they’ve died.
The theory looks at grief like this: While many think grief is just an emotional response to the death of a loved one, these psychologists claim it actually evolved from a way to motivate our ancestors to search for someone who was lost — literally.
Thus, based on the reunion theory, grief causes people to search for a lost loved one, even if subconsciously. Because of that, seeing a glimpse of your dog might not actually be that unusual. Others have added to the reunion theory with their own studies, claiming the “signs” people see are actually “false recognitions.” In a subconscious attempt to find their dead loved ones, even the smallest resemblance of sight, sound or smell might trigger a false recognition.
These recognitions aren’t completely false, though — a sound similar to a dog’s sigh or the jingle of their collar might be entirely real — but because of that internal longing, they’re simply misinterpreted by those who experience them.
Hear what the Long Island Medium has to say about this woman’s deceased dog:
Differentiating Between Signs and Science
There’s no way to truly tell whether dogs’ spirits remain after they die.
Ask someone who’s witnessed a sign from the afterlife, and you’d likely be met with spiritual recountings. Ask Claire White or Dan Fessler, who studied false recognitions of dead pets, and you’d come up against well-researched evidence to the contrary.
That, of course, begs the question: What do you believe? Have you witnessed a sign from your pet in the afterlife, or are you standing by science, research and reason? Tell us in the comments below.